Rank Team Seasons W L W % RS RA
1 Columbus Wolves, Ohio Hurricanes 3 47 24 0.662 750 507
2 Celina Group Bandits, Columbus Bandits, Columbus Bullets 5 77 41 0.653 1015 735
3 Bison All Star Baseball Club, Bison Baseball Club 22 323 183 0.638 4085 2576
4 Columbus Bombers 6 90 46 0.662 1152 676
5 Campus Catfish, Columbus Bulls 6 58 86 0.403 869 1076
6 Lancaster Huskies 3 30 36 0.455 436 480
7 Ohio Indians 7 123 44 0.737 1461 792
8 Lancaster Jaguars 1 7 17 0.292 143 237
9 Panini's Punishers, 4 Kegs Brewers 3 14 57 0.197 305 806
10 Central Ohio Ravens, Central Ohio Cyclones, Central Ohio Ravens 6 49 93 0.345 854 1231
11 Hebron Renegades 14 198 139 0.588 2417 1874
12 Columbus Rockies 1 1 23 0.042 89 245
13 Columbus Spitballers 9 127 90 0.585 1756 1393
14 Hamilton Twp Vipers, Hamilton Twp Black Sox 7 100 70 0.588 1211 923
15 Marion County Fusion 2 18 30 0.375 274 348
16 Columbus Hammerhead Sharks, Columbus Knights 18 295 125 0.702 3555 1898
17 Aardvarks, Stars 3 17 57 0.230 388 727
18 Columbus Barracudas 20 265 188 0.585 3321 2565
19 Columbus Predators 2 17 32 0.347 234 394
20 Columbus Vengeance 1 0 26 0.000 51 384
21 Columbus Red Devilz 10 139 101 0.579 1765 1361
22 Nimrods, Columbus Bobcats 6 48 98 0.329 811 1267
23 Cardinals 1 4 18 0.182 90 201
24 Colt 45's 5 64 58 0.525 874 849
25 North Columbus Bears 8 88 104 0.458 1204 1235
26 Columbus Express 3 24 50 0.324 404 724
27 CurtsBSC Cougars 1 10 14 0.417 161 200
28 Westerville Titans 5 105 16 0.868 1192 471
29 Rampage Baseball Club 2 28 22 0.560 462 360
30 Central Ohio Wildcats 5 35 88 0.285 582 1235
31 Columbus Colts 1 2 22 0.083 125 301
32 Columbus Privateers 2 7 43 0.140 260 524
33 Columbus Cubs 1 1 25 0.038 71 349
34 County Heat 5 30 84 0.263 548 1072
35 Columbus Braves, Columbus Warriors 6 50 86 0.368 631 1029
36 Columbus Piranhas, Columbus Clydesdales 3 16 54 0.229 249 532
37 Ohio Grizzlies, Columbus Coyotes 11 54 185 0.226 936 2136
38 North Dublin Irish 5 35 76 0.315 406 844
39 Columbus Jets 2 2 46 0.042 147 563
40 Columbus Black Hawks 2 43 6 0.878 416 111
41 Worthington Tigers 9 139 51 0.732 1445 649
42 Franklin County Royals 1 9 15 0.375 115 165
43 Columbus Angels 5 46 59 0.438 684 696
44 Columbus Dragons 1 3 21 0.125 73 261
45 Ohio Mariners 5 36 65 0.356 636 833
46 Columbus Red Sox 5 36 66 0.353 565 881
47 Columbus Bearcats 5 56 50 0.528 713 711
48 Ohio Rockies 1 15 7 0.682 139 88
49 MSBL 6 50 97 0.340 927 1363
50 Columbus Kings 6 87 39 0.690 1005 587
51 Central Ohio Rockies, Columbus Padres, Columbus Brewers 4 22 62 0.262 402 773
52 Westerville Expos 4 60 22 0.732 710 322
53 Ohio Pirates 4 48 36 0.571 590 400
54 Columbus Latins 2 26 16 0.619 290 241
55 Ohio Blue Jays 3 40 23 0.635 480 334
56 Columbus Rays 2 6 36 0.143 162 478
57 Elite Fire, Gahanna Bananas 3 24 39 0.381 287 477
58 Terriers Baseball Club, Columbus Commodores 2 8 34 0.190 147 303
59 Zanesville Sr. Pioneers 2 25 16 0.610 253 127
60 Diamondbacks Baseball Club 1 1 20 0.048 36 346
61 Columbus Mustangs 1 1 20 0.048 33 299
62 Dugout Baseball 1 19 1 0.950 206 30